Volume 53 (2016)

Volume 53 (2016) / Issue 4

Charlotte O’brien, 'Civis capitalist sum: Class as the new guiding principle of EU free movement rights' (2016) 53 Common Market Law Review, Issue 4, pp. 937–977


As the last traces of EU citizenship disappear, the definitional boundary between work and inactivity becomes more critical. The ECJ’s increasing tolerance of nationality-discrimination creates a moral vacuum at the heart of free movement law, which is being exploited by Member States to impose their own definitions of work. Migrant workers on low incomes and in insecure jobs are at risk of exclusion from any equal treatment, which is especially concerning as labour market patterns change and zero hours contracts proliferate. The working poor are alienated, while the benefits of free movement are reserved for the better resourced. These domestic distortions of EU law feed back into, and distort in turn, EU law at its source – a prime example being the proposed “in-work benefit brake” in the UK-EU new settlement.

Copyright © 2016 Kluwer Law International
All rights reserved

ISSN: 0165-0750
ID: COLA2016089