European Review of Private Law

Volume 26 (2018)

Volume 26 (2018) / Issue 5

Pascal Mcdougall, 'Policy, Politics and Aesthetics in Non-American Private Law: A Comparative Study of Contract Performance Interruption' (2018) 26 European Review of Private Law, Issue 5, pp. 597–634


Abstract: In the United States, it is widely accepted that ‘policy,’ meaning conflicting societal values and interests that can be weighed, plays an important role in private law reasoning. However, in many other polities, including France, England, Quebec and English Canada which this article scrutinizes, the role of policy in private law is either strenuously denied or reduced to an exceptional consideration of social concerns under residual doctrines like good faith, abuse of right or unconscionability. As a result, full-blown and routine invocations of policy are still considered to be an exotic American feature and to be absent from these systems. In this article, I refute this persisting view and show that such policy arguments are as a matter of fact relied on by authoritative actors in France, England, Quebec and English Canada. Taking interruption of contractual performance following breach as a case study, I rely on cases and treatises from these four jurisdictions to produce an integrated repertoire of policy arguments that have been invoked for a series of related contract law questions. I thus provide the basis for the application of American private law insights in legal systems where they have largely been ignored. I suggest that there are important political and aesthetic stakes to this jurisprudential transplantation, in that it allows for innovative forms of contestation of marketbased normative reasoning and of the traditional professional styles adopted by non- American jurists.

Copyright © 2018 Kluwer Law International
All rights reserved

ISSN: 0928-9801
ID: ERPL2018042