Volume 47 (2013)

Volume 47 (2013) / Issue 5

Dukgeun Ahn, Jihong Lee, Jee-Hyeong Park, 'Understanding Non-litigated Disputes in the WTO Dispute Settlement System' (2013) 47 Journal of World Trade, Issue 5, pp. 985–1012

Abstract

This article focuses on a less scrutinized aspect of the WTO dispute settlement system - non-litigated disputes. Legal rules concerning consultation and settlement during the panel proceedings are analysed with the case laws. We then propose, and empirically analyse, several key economic determinants of non-litigation in the WTO dispute settlement system that are motivated by the theory of bargaining with informational asymmetry. In particular, our logistic regressions show that a greater difference in the size of the pair of disputing countries reduces the likelihood of voluntary settlement or non-litigation. WTO members also tend to prefer non-litigation when the respondent is smaller than the complainant, has less reputational concern, and faces less retaliatory capacity of the complainant. Our findings suggest a case for reforming the legal rules of the consultation process towards mitigating informational asymmetry or improving communication between disputing parties in the WTO.

Copyright © 2013 Kluwer Law International
All rights reserved

ISSN: 1011-6702
ID: TRAD2013033