Volume 36 (2013)

Volume 36 (2013) / Issue 1

Małgorzata Sadowska, Bert Willems, 'Market Integration and Economic Efficiency at Conflict? Commitments in the Swedish Interconnectors Case' (2013) 36 World Competition, Issue 1, pp. 99–132

Keywords:
competition policy, Article 102 TFEU, commitment decisions, European energy markets, transmission congestion, Swedish network operator

Abstract

According to the European Commission, Svenska Kraftnät, the Swedish network operator, might have violated competition rules by limiting cross-border transmission capacity to relieve congestion within Sweden. Eventually, the case was settled and Svenska Kraftnät offered commitments to address the Commission's concerns. As an interim remedy, it committed to reduce transmission flow of electricity on internal network bottlenecks primarily by introducing national measures and by not reducing interconnection capacity. As a final remedy, Svenska Kraftnät agreed to split the Swedish market into multiple price zones. Congestion within Sweden would then be solved by adjusting the prices of those zones.

We analyse the economic effects of the alleged abuse and the remedy package. We make three observations. First, it might be socially optimal to reduce cross-border capacity in response to internal congestion. Hence, without an in-depth economic analysis the Commission risked preventing efficient behaviour. Second, the interim remedy of handling internal congestion primarily by national measures is not socially optimal, and it cannot be ruled out that it reduces overall welfare. Third, even though splitting the market into price zones may improve allocative efficiency within Sweden, it does not prevent Svenska Kraftnät from potential manipulation of cross-border transmission capacity.

Copyright © 2013 Kluwer Law International
All rights reserved

ISSN: 1011-4548
ID: WOCO2013006